Macromedia Development Application Comparison

 

Dreamweaver

Flash

Fireworks

Best used for

Creating html file, beginning to intermediate Web pages

Creating an animated or interactive movie, creating a self-contained Web environment (scenes instead of pages)

Creating animated gif, drawing, graphic images.

Type of File it creates

.html file

Can insert files created in other applications (.gif, .jpg) made in Photoshop, Fireworks, etc.

.fla movie
Exports .html file that calls .swf movie

Can import files created in other applications (.gif, .jpg) made in Photoshop, Illustrator, Fireworks, etc.

.png file
Exports .htm(l) file that calls .gif files (can choose just to export .gif)

Can import files created in other applications (.gif, .jpg) made in Photoshop, Illustrator, etc.

Type of code it writes

HTML, some Javascript-easy to troubleshoot and modify in other Web editor (like Composer or GoLive) or text editor (like Simpletext or Notepad).

Proprietary Flash code-must be created and modified in Flash program

Writes HTML, Javascript, and makes .gif files. Difficult to debug if you don't understand Javascript.

Accessibility

Most functions supported by most browsers. Layers not supported by all browsers giving inconsistent results.

Requires Flash plug-in to run on Web. Slow on low bandwidth; self-contained environment renders browser buttons and features useless (Back button, etc.), low accessibility for handicapped.

Most functions supported by most browsers. Creates many files. All files must be loaded on Web space for page to work.

Animation

Some movement and tweening, simple rollovers

Full animation and interactivity, complex rollovers

Animated gif, frames, and Javascript capability

Advanced Features

Javascript Behaviors

Javascript Actions, decent drawing capabilities

Javascript Behaviors; advanced drawing and effect capabilities

Comparable Applications

Adobe GoLive, Netscape Composer, Microsoft Frontpage

Adobe After Effects

Adobe Photoshop/Image Ready, Adobe Live Motion